Private lenders are increasingly recognizing that the availability and affordability of property insurance are critical factors in underwriting real estate loans. Difficulties in securing insurance—whether due to regulatory rate caps, catastrophic risks, or market withdrawals—can elevate lender risk, affect property values, and complicate loan enforcement.
This article highlights the importance of insurance access and identifies U.S. states where real estate lending is most and least favorable from an insurance perspective in 2025.
Why Insurance Availability Matters for Private Lenders
- Collateral Protection: Property insurance protects the lender’s collateral against loss from fire, natural disasters, and liability claims. Without adequate insurance, lenders risk unprotected exposure.
- Loan Enforceability: Many loan agreements require borrowers to maintain insurance. If insurance is unavailable or canceled, lenders may be forced to pay premiums or accelerate default remedies.
- Property Value Stability: Insurance difficulties often correlate with declining market confidence, affecting property values and resale prospects.
- Regulatory and Compliance Risks: Lenders must ensure loans meet regulatory guidelines, including insurance coverage requirements.
States with the WORST Insurance Conditions for Real Estate Lending
These states face insurer pullbacks, high premiums, or regulatory challenges causing insurance scarcity or cost spikes:
- California
- Wildfire risk and strict rate caps have led many insurers to reduce coverage, especially in high-risk areas.
- Limited insurance availability increases risk for lenders financing properties in wildfire zones.
- Florida
- Hurricane exposure, coupled with litigation over sinkhole claims and assignment of benefits abuse, has caused insurer exits and high premiums.
- Market instability impacts loan collateral risk.
- Louisiana
- Similar to Florida, hurricane risk and litigation have led to insurer market shrinkage and reliance on state-backed insurers.
- Insurance access challenges persist, raising lending risks.
- Texas (Certain Regions)
- Catastrophic weather events (hailstorms, floods) and regulatory constraints cause premium volatility and insurer caution.
- Some markets see limited insurer competition.
- Hawaii
- High premiums and limited competition increase costs and reduce insurance availability, especially for coastal properties.
States with the BEST Insurance Conditions for Real Estate Lending
These states have more stable insurance markets, broader coverage options, and fewer regulatory constraints:
- Ohio
- Competitive insurance markets and lower catastrophe risks contribute to broad availability and reasonable premiums.
- Pennsylvania
- A stable regulatory environment and diverse insurer presence make it easier to obtain affordable insurance.
- Michigan
- Moderate weather risks and competitive insurance landscape support strong insurance availability.
- Indiana
- Limited catastrophe exposure and a healthy insurer market make for reliable insurance options.
- Colorado
- While wildfire risks exist, regulatory frameworks and insurer competition generally keep insurance accessible.
What Private Lenders Should Do
- Conduct Local Market Insurance Analysis: Evaluate insurance market conditions in the loan location, focusing on availability, premiums, and regulatory environment.
- Include Insurance Contingencies: Draft loan agreements requiring borrower insurance and lender notification on cancellations or coverage changes.
- Assess Alternative Risk Mitigation: Consider additional protections such as escrow accounts for premiums or lender-placed insurance as a last resort.
- Consult Legal and Insurance Experts: Partner with specialists to understand evolving insurance landscapes and compliance requirements.
In 2025, private lenders must go beyond traditional credit and property assessments to include insurance market realities. Lending in states with fragile insurance markets heightens risk and requires enhanced diligence and contractual protections.
Geraci LLP offers specialized legal counsel to help lenders navigate these complexities, ensuring loans are structured to manage insurance risks effectively.
Contact Geraci LLP
